Integrity and Wrongdoing

Note:

  • Media added
  • Content added and revised
  • References corrected

Prejudice is often a phenomenon not only in our general daily lives, but in the work environment as well, especially when the job entails working mainly with other human beings. Human beings are quick to judge others and often don’t sweep in front of their own door before they litter on someone else’s doorstep.

During a clinical rotation this year, I was confronted with a situation that I found particularly difficult to approach and handle. In the back of my mind I knew what the right thing to do was, but I was doubting myself as the situation involved a colleague – the community service physiotherapist.

As healthcare professionals/students working in the healthcare provision sector, we are required by law to document interactions with patients and document all relevant information regarding an assessment and treatment session. These SOAP notes that are documented in the patient’s medical folder is seen as a legal document that can be used as evidence or reference in a court of law. Thus, the importance of proper and accurate documentation cannot be over emphasized.

On this particular block, on numerous occasions, it came to my attention that the particular colleague would go to the patient’s bed, not greet them, open their folder, write in it, and walk away. At some point these patients would be referred to students for physiotherapy treatment. It then came to my attention that this colleague would write up a treatment session (very cryptically) without actually ever treating the patient physically or verbally.

I was very unsure of how to handle the situation. Should I confront her about it? Should I rather go to my superior first? Should I keep quiet and not risk a hostile work environment?

Dr. Lawrence Wilson (2014) states that the concept of integrity refers to being “whole”, “complete”, balanced in one’s life and lifestyle, honesty, truth-seeking, reliability, authenticity and consistency in all areas of your life. Furthermore, these must be your principles of living and truth is the most essential component of integrity.

Professional misconduct or unprofessional behaviour can be defined as behaviour outside the bound of what is considered acceptable or worthy of its membership by the governing body of a profession (Neale, 1996).

In my opinion, the behaviour of the specific colleague would classify as professional misconduct as the occupation requires the healthcare provider to provide a service of high quality that is effective and efficient. Even though SOAP notes are written, the patient never received the service he/she is entitled to. This opinion is supported by the Acts of Professional misconduct which states that failing to maintain a standard of practice of the profession or contravening a standard of practice of the profession as set out in the by-laws is an act of professional misconduct (OPFA, n.d.). But now, if I did not report what I have noticed, will that also fall under professional misconduct? And what about my integrity?

I tried to understand the reason behind her behaviour in attempt to give her the benefit of the doubt and to understand the nature of her wrongdoing. It seemed as if her professional commitments have been compromised by her personal need for earning a living while still maintaining prestige and authority. Could this possible be due to poor character or a lack of integrity? Or purely just due to poor time management?

Casey (2000) explores ten causes for professional misconduct which include:

  1. Failure to maintain currency of professional knowledge and competence
  2. Failure to seek assistance or make appropriate referrals
  3. Difficulties in a professional’s personal life affecting their work life
  4. Alcohol and drug addictions
  5. Poor communication
  6. Failure to appropriately address patient concerns
  7. Environmental factors
  8. Personality conflicts escalate to professional misconduct
  9. Complacency about professional standards
  10. Professional documentation

There are many different reasons for why an individual could act unprofessionally. In conclusion, lack of rational self-control due to moral weakness and moral indifference due to lack of concern for other as well as moral detachment are some of the main reasons for professional misconduct which indirectly links to one’s integrity in the workplace.

References

Casey, J. (2000). Top Ten Causes of Unprofessional Conduct. Retrieved on September 29th, 2016 from http://www.fieldlaw.com/articles/jtc_top10causes.pdf

Neale, A. (1996). Professional conduct and professional misconduct: A framework and its application to the accounting profession. Journal of Business Ethics, 15(2), 219-226.

Professional Misconduct Defined | Ontario Professional Foresters Association. (n.d.). Retrieved on 29 September 2016 from https://secure.opfa.ca/regulation-enforcement/regulation-profession/general-standards-guidelines-members/professional

Wilson, L. (2014). Integrity – What it is and what it means. Retrieved on September 29th, 2016 from http://drlwilson.com/Articles/INTEGRITY.htm

Advertisements

3 Replies to “Integrity and Wrongdoing”

  1. Hello Mia 😀

    This was a really interesting story although I am sure it wasn’t easy to decide what to do. I at one point felt like there should be a part two for this post because I was eager to know how the story ended. I hope that you were happy and at peace with whatever decision you decided to make. Here are a few points that could hopefully help you improve your future posts:

    You have good content, and you touched on the major points of the topics. I felt as though you could have explored the topic a bit deeper. You describe a lot on the meaning of certain ideas which is great as it helps us understand better, but It would be nice if you went a step further with those ideas and explored it a bit more. Expand your literature to build up a case for your story.

    Just a minor error noticed with references, if I am not mistaken the Web Page reference should be month date, year, link.. example, with your first reference:
    Casey, J. (2000). Top Ten Causes of Unprofessional Conduct. Retrieved on September 29, 2016, from http://www.fieldlaw.com/articles/jtc_top10causes.pdf
    Other than that, it was good and you show evidence of research using many different sources.

    No major errors in spelling or grammar. You are quite clear and to the point which is very nice and refreshing. Your thoughts are not clustered and it allows your sentences to be understandable.

    I do see that you speak for both view points and thats great. Maybe adding more literature to back up a few of these points could make your argument stronger.

    Your cover image is lovely, straight forward and not so harsh to the eye compared to a few other covers that I have seen. I think you could have created a more catchy title to grab the readers attention and make it stand out from the rest. Good use of links, tags and categories. It would have also kept the post more captivating along the way if there were images, art or videos between paragraphs that emphasized a certain point, topic or even the paragraph itself.

    Thanks for sharing this post Mia and I hope that these comments will guide you in your future posts. All the best !

    Carina Goorye

    Like

  2. Hi Mia

    I really enjoyed reading this blog post as it was quite intriguing. Its also interesting how you finished the post without revealing what you did at the end. It creates the opportunity for the reader to actually place themselves in that situation and decide on what they would have done.

    With regards to:
    Content: I think that you did a good job here. The content cover the major concepts and in-text references clearly show that you did consult additional resources.
    References: I think that you made good use of the sources and it provide good support to write-up.
    Structure: Good structure and very minimal grammatical errors noted.
    Argument: Writing shows arguments for different points of views, which are good.
    Technology: You made good use of the technology.

    Good job!

    Milton Geduld

    Like

  3. Hi Mia

    I can definitely relate to your situation as I have experienced something similar. It may appear easy, but when you are confronted by such a situation, you realized that it is not as easy as you thought it would be.

    In the medical profession you are not only required to do what is right by law for the patient, but also for yourself worth, to add value to your morals and principles.

    Again, well structured and implementation of references. May I suggest that for future blogging, you could add more media to enhance your reading piece.

    Thank you for sharing.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s